Should the testimony of Imam ‘Ali’s (a) wilayah be said in the tashahhud?
No. Belief in the wilayah of the Commander of the Faithful, ‘Ali (a), is the foundation of Shia belief, but the testimony to his wilayah (known as the “third testimony”) is not part of the tashahhud of the prayer, and the maraji‘ agree that it is wrong to treat it as obligatory there. According to Grand Ayatullah Sayyid ‘Ali al-Sistani, the obligatory precaution is not to say it in the tashahhud (a reply of Ayatullah Sistani’s office). Followers of other maraji‘ should check their own marja‘’s ruling.
The place of wilayah
This ruling in no way means that the wilayah matters less. Al-Kafi records the well-known narration of Imam Muhammad al-Baqir (a) that Islam is built on five things — prayer, zakat, fasting, hajj and the wilayah — and that nothing was called to as the wilayah was called to. The wilayah is a belief of the heart and a path for the whole of life; the prayer is accepted with it. But the words and pillars of the prayer are those the Messenger of Allah (s) and the Imams (a) taught, and no sentence may be added to them on our own as a part of the prayer.
The adhan and the tashahhud are different
Saying “Ash-hadu anna ‘Aliyyan waliyyullah” in the adhan and iqamah is a distinctive sign of the Shia, and the maraji‘ regard it as good and rewarding, provided it is not said as a part of the adhan (Ayatullah Sistani, Islamic Laws, ruling 905). The adhan is an announcement before the prayer, while the tashahhud is an obligatory part of the prayer itself, with its words fixed in the narrations. That is why the two do not share one ruling.
Answers from Ayatullah Sistani’s office
His office was asked about the third testimony in the tashahhud. The answer: the obligatory precaution is to leave it out. His office in the United States explains what this means: saying it in the tashahhud invalidates the prayer, based on obligatory precaution — so whoever said it knowing the ruling should pray that prayer again.
A question was asked about a woman who for years had recited the tashahhud with “wa ‘Aliyyan waliyyullah” added. The answer: if her ignorance was qusuri (she had no reason or opportunity to learn the ruling), she owes no qada; if it was taqsiri (she could have learnt it and did not), she should make those prayers up as an obligatory precaution (a reply of Ayatullah Sistani’s office).
Anyone who has been doing this should not be distressed: find out your marja‘’s ruling, recite the correct tashahhud from now on, and ask him about the past prayers as well.
The argument sometimes offered
Some people draw the conclusion that the testimony of wilayah is obligatory in the prayer from certain narrations quoted in the commentary on Surah al-Isra’ (Bani Isra’il), verse 110, and Surah al-Hijr, verse 94. These are narrations of interpretation (ta’wil); their chains are weak or incomplete, and even if accepted, they speak of proclaiming the wilayah, not of adding words to the tashahhud. The form of the prayer is taken from the clear narrations that deal specifically with the prayer, and on that basis no marja‘ holds this testimony to be obligatory in the tashahhud.
Where to affirm the wilayah
Affirming the Imams after the prayer, in the ta‘qibat, is recommended, and in one short ta‘qib narrated from the Ahl al-Bayt (a) the worshipper names the twelve Imams (a) and declares them his Imams. In this way the wilayah is proclaimed with full dignity right after the prayer, and the fixed words of the prayer stay intact.
The correct tashahhud and its recommended additions: Salah › Salah Questions & Answers › “Which tashahhud should be recited in salah, and is a longer one better?” · The testimony of wilayah in the adhan: Salah › Salah Questions & Answers › “Why do Shia say “Ashhadu anna ‘Aliyyan waliyyullah” in the adhan?”
The ta‘qib affirming the Imams after every prayer: Salah › How to Perform Salat › “Tasbih of Fatimah (a) and the Sajdah of Thanks”
Sources: al-Kafi, Kitab al-Iman wa al-Kufr (Bab Da‘a’im al-Islam); istifta’ answers of Ayatullah Sistani’s office; Ayatullah Sistani, Islamic Laws, ruling 905. Check your own marja‘’s ruling.
اَللّٰهُمَّ صَلِّ عَلٰى مُحَمَّدٍ وَّاٰلِ مُحَمَّدٍ